Is it even possible to give 110%?
Mathematically, it’s worth asking. 110% of what? Your average output? Your theoretical maximum? The number itself doesn’t hold up, and neither does the expectation behind it.
Here in the US, especially, sports analogies are used all the time. Leave it all on the field. Empty the tank. Give everything you’ve got.
I get the sentiment. There are absolutely moments that call for everything you have. A make-or-break deadline. The product launch that needs you to be fully present. The challenging conversation you’ve been putting off that finally has to happen. Those moments are real, and showing up fully for them matters.
I know this firsthand. For years, I wore all-in output as a badge of honor. Running at peak all the time felt like evidence of commitment, of seriousness, of being the kind of leader worth following. In hindsight, I was beyond wrong. Going all out, all the time, isn’t strength. It’s a fast track to diminished returns, poor judgment, and eventual burnout.
The data back this up. And so does a philosopher who figured this out 2,400 years ago.
Aristotle Had a Name for This
Aristotle called it the Golden Mean.
Virtue lives in the middle, between excess and deficiency.
Too much of something tips into a vice. Too little does the same. The goal is balance, calibrated to the situation in front of you.
Aristotle’s Golden Mean has been applied to character strengths, the basic building blocks of a flourishing life. In this framework, any of our 24 character strengths can be overused or underused. Overusing curiosity can come across as nosy, and underusing it can look like disengagement. Overuse of perseverance becomes stubbornness. Underuse can seem like a lack of motivation.
That’s the lens. Now, apply it to how you actually show up at work.
Peak vs. Optimal
Peak performance is real. It’s also episodic by design. Athletes who train at peak intensity every single session don’t get stronger. They actually risk injury. The science of athletic training has known this for decades. You build in cycles of high intensity and recovery, and the peak moments mean something because of the work done around them.
Leadership works the same way.
There are presentations that deserve your full preparation, and ones where good-enough is genuinely good enough. There are weeks that call for nights and weekends, and stretches where protecting your recovery is the most strategic thing you can do. There are conversations where you need to bring everything, and others where a light touch is the right call.
The problem is that giving in to the 110% culture collapses all of these into a single mode. Full throttle, all the time.
Research on the overuse and underuse of character strengths makes the cost explicit. Chronic overuse of your strengths, driven by an assumption that more is always better, is associated with lower flourishing and life satisfaction. Optimal use, by contrast, correlates with higher well-being and less depression.
Optimal Best As the Standard
Optimal best means showing up fully for what the moment actually requires. Not less than that, and not more.
Some days look like a surge. A long night, an extra push, full intensity because the situation genuinely calls for it. Other days it looks like a steady, grounded 80% because you have things going on at home, your energy is lower, or you’re in a recovery week after a heavy sprint. Both are appropriate and intentional.
The mistake is treating the peak as the baseline, and everything else is falling short.
Aristotle wasn’t arguing for mediocrity. In fact, he was championing quite the opposite. The ability to read a situation and calibrate your response to what it actually needs. Leaders who master this outperform the ones who don’t..
So, Now What?
A few ways to start practicing optimal use instead of defaulting to peak:
Name your surges. Before committing to a full-on push, ask: does this moment actually require it? Be intentional with your time and energy.
Learn your overuse patterns. Look at your top character strengths. Where do you tend to overdo them? Where are you holding back? Awareness is the first step toward calibration.
Build in recovery as a strategy. Block recovery intentionally the same way you’d block a critical meeting. A lighter week after a heavy sprint is a performance decision and not a sign of weakness. It’s a sign of being intentional.
In some ways, it’s easier to just give it your all. Go into autopilot mode and just go. However, this is not sustainable. Our energy responds better to a dial that allows us to adapt in the moment.
#VIACharacterStrengths #TheGoldeMean